Talking To The Screen
The Killing Fields :1984
'The Killing Fields' tells a true-ish story of New York Times reporter Sidney Schanberg's experiences in 1970's Cambodia. More specifically, this film focuses on the experiences of Sidney's interpreter and guide, Dith Pran, a Cambodian, fluent in English and French. In order to enjoy and be moved by this movie, the viewer ought to have a decent understanding of what exactly happened in Cambodia in the mid 1970's. I didn't. Going into this, I knew the following: Pol Pot's Khmer Rouge regime executed a successful communist revolution. The subsequent Cambodian communist government was particularly brutal, killing many of its citizens. 'The Killing Fields' does an excellent job of adding strong moving visual imagery to an otherwise foggy subject. However, the story that's being told is somewhat discontinuous, confusing and poorly constructed. The film is strongly dissected by The Khmer Rouge's capture of Phnom Penh, the capitol of Cambodia. Before The Khmer Rouge's victory, the story focuses on Sidney Schanberg (Sam Waterston) and his journalistic quest for truth. Interestingly (or maybe I should say, inconsistently), the only story that we see Pran and Sidney work on together, outside of the Phnom Penh, investigates an errant bombing run by the US. In a movie that ultimately centers around the terrors of the Khmer Rouge and their subsequent government, it would certainly be more appropriate to feature a story about the revolutionaries. As the viewer is introduced to the characters in the setting of a western error and cover up, I was expecting a story about the US influence on the Cambodian crisis. Instead, the second half of the movie takes a drastic turn. After the successful siege of Phnom Penh, The Khmer Rouge kicked all foreigners out of Cambodia. Sidney returns to New York. Pran is abandoned in Cambodia where he lives an arduous existence picking rice and gathering clay for the communist regime. The action of the film at this point shifts to Dith Pran's struggles in Cambodia. Occasionally, scenes of Sidney in New York pining for word of Pran's survival are interspersed. This second half of the film while visually stunning, slows to a near halt. First of all, none of the Cambodian is subtitled. While this was understandable in the first half, where Sidney spoke no Cambodian, and Pran served as his interpreter, in the second half this affect was simply frustrating. There are some speeches by communist leaders that assuredly would have been moving and enticing. Unfortunately, I wouldn't know. Occasionally, every five minutes or so, Pran delivers a voiceover. This helps alleviate the frustration, but not enough. Basically, 'The Killing Fields' is as discombobulated a movie as this is a review. Haing S. Ngor is brilliant as Dith Pran and makes the film watchable. Apart from that, scenes are often presented without explanation. The music is aggravating. Also, and possibly more damaging, I didn't know this was a true story until the film was over. 'The Killing Fields' is not as good as, it seems, everyone thinks. I strongly recommend not watching this movie. I was totally unimpressed.